ExploreTrendingAnalytics
Nostr Archives
ExploreTrendingAnalytics
Tauri22d ago
I’ve read the proposal and a bunch of opinions from both sides to form an opinion. For example you quote certain passages from the website/github and interpret them in a way that fits your view. I read them and I interpret them in the opposite direction. The problem BIP110 addresses is severe enough to tighten the rules significantly but not to the point they break the foundations. In fact they reinforce them. Ironically the top down decision making of Core v30 made this fork necessary not just in principle but in practice. If you don’t know what I talk about it maybe you haven’t paid enough attention, or you simply prefer to think it’s a nothingburger. Maybe you should have applied this higher standard towards protocol development to Bitcoin Core too. Did you? Are you running v30? If not, why?
💬 1 replies

Thread context

Root: a0d09a42ddf0…

Replying to: f463c55b5137…

Replies (1)

HHide&Seek22d ago
I am opposed to core v30 for the exact same reasons I am opposed to BIP110: sloppy engineering forced through the community with poor arguments. Btw, core v30 didn't enable posting contiguous harmful content on chain: it was enabled in 2013 by OP_RETURN, that was limitless at the consensus level from the start. And to be clear, the threat was well known all along. There are press articles from 2018/2019 that were FUDing about it during that bear. Anyone who's familiar with bitcoin, like Luke also is, has knew about this for years if not a decade — so why is it suddenly an emergency after all that time? Core 30 sucks and it shouldn't have happen - but it is simply not true that it made that attack viable, and anyone who thinks so is deeply miseducated about how bitcoin works. All of this is just ego war and people wanting to feel great about themselves. If the priority was to protect bitcoin against this attack, then capping OP_RETURN size would have been enough, and much much more likely to pass. But ofc they had to overdo and turn this into a personal vendetta, and now the chances of fixing the actual important thing by the end or the year are 0.
0000 sats