ExploreTrendingAnalytics
Nostr Archives
ExploreTrendingAnalytics
おくなも(早く寝ろ)15d ago
おお!コメントあった。 https://github.com/coinbase/x402/pull/1311#issuecomment-3…
💬 12 replies

Replies (12)

René Aaron15d ago
Has anyone looked into making bitcoin / lightning work with x402 yet? @50d94fc2…df281d63 @Matt Corallo @15b5cf6c…0875315e
0000 sats
Matt Corallo15d ago
It was originally included in AP2, but then x402 was created and then coinbase kinda stopped accepting PRs and seems focused entirely on USDC…not sure it’s worth bothering with vs just using L402.
0000 sats
おくなも(早く寝ろ)15d ago
Hi this is working PoC. https://simpl402.ocknamo.com/
0000 sats
René Aaron15d ago
Nice! Do you run the facilitator yourself in this PoC? Or do you just implement the x402 schematics?
0000 sats
René Aaron15d ago
Okay, thanks for sharing your opinion!
0000 sats
おくなも(早く寝ろ)15d ago
I just implemented the x402 flow itself. I’m not running a facilitator — I’m using the Coinos API for payment verification.
0000 sats
René Aaron14d ago
Okay, but that needs you (the merchant) to implement the verify / settle methods yourself? Would it still make sense in your opinion to have a x402 bitcoin facilitator to make integration into projects easier and compatible with official libraries in @x402/*?
0000 sats
おくなも(早く寝ろ)14d ago
Yes, the merchant implements it. For on-chain payments, a facilitator makes a lot of sense since someone needs to handle submission and confirmation on-chain. But with Lightning being inherently peer-to-peer, I’m not sure a facilitator adds much value. Payment verification can already be handled directly by the merchant’s node, so introducing a facilitator might just add an extra layer rather than solve a real problem.
0000 sats
René Aaron14d ago
I had similar thoughts. It's not necessarily useful for the flow, but maybe the "compatibility" with x402 and being able to get bitcoin into the hands of x402 folks maybe? Analyzed some data from Coinbase CDP x402 discovery API:
0000 sats
おくなも(早く寝ろ)14d ago
A facilitator is not mandatory in x402 either, so compatibility is not an issue. However, it may have value in terms of making integration easier.
0000 sats
René Aaron14d ago
Oh, okay 👍 Do you have any input on the flow of verify / settle that usually is used with x402 and how that works different with lightning? https://github.com/getAlby/x402-facilitator?tab=readme-ov… The facilitator is supposed to only settle the transaction after the order is successfully fulfilled.
0000 sats