There's definitely more engagement when people make content specifically for nostr. The intention behind the content is different. I don't blame anyone for cross posting. There are a lot of platforms to keep track of and for bigger names the money is not on nostr. The real engagement comes from creators that engage with the comments on their posts in a genuine way. That's a rare event when it happens.

I’m fine with it. Some of the social media platforms provide the tools that make it dirt simple to create contents. I may have a problem with TikTok and Facebook, but doesn’t mean I have a problem with some of the content.

I’m fine with it, as long as they are using Nostr in spreading their content, and hopefully over time start engaging and migrating their data more on Nostr

Too many ppl on any social media platforms are just attention seekers. I prefer to be authentic. I know that not everyone will like what I say etc. I'm not here to become popular lol. There were times I had more than enough of publicity in my life. When I look back it was time when my life was destroyed. Reason was my ego. Long story short. Something like that in English.

Ya, You can totally feel it when it’s a cross post. But Nostr wants alllll the information. So I’m happy to see it

for me its to see how people respond to my ideas so i can refine them

People are free to use Nostr however they wish so if cross posting from other platforms is what they want to do then I don’t have a problem with it. I do agree with you that more personalised content targeted toward the audience is likely to be better received. I think engagement can be a strange thing on Nostr sometimes though. Without algorithms I’ve found that it can vary a lot even with simple things like the time of day that you are posting.

I agree and I’ve seen a few discussions recently about the need for better mechanisms to discover content on Nostr. At the moment the only real option is to repost things that you don’t feel got the visibility that you expected. I occasionally repost 8-12 hours later if there is something I think the other half of the world may be interested in seeing. I personally don’t want a fully algorithmic feed but algorithms that can be enabled to see notes that I missed while sleeping or to help discover new unique content would be useful.

I'm trying to understand it too. Been crossposting some of my things from here to other platforms, as Nostr has become my central platform for content spreading.

I don't really mind "how" people post, as long as it is relevant on Nostr and they do respond on Nostr. To me, it seems a bit off if it is posted from some other network, like say X, and all the links are X links. Or if it is just a bunch of posts and the creator never engages or responds on Nostr. That said they can post whatever they want, I may not follow them though.

It's good in either way.. Nostr needs content.. the less people have to switch back to their Fiat-world to get the iinfo they're hearing about, the more it's probable they'll stay.

Agree

Yeah I see this happen sometimes. My feed gets flooded with reposts because someone wakes up and decides to repost everything they posted the previous day all at once! I try to limit my reposts only to notes that I think people might have missed and would find interesting, or sometimes quote repost if there is additional useful information that I can add.